Common Sense Dog · Food database · Diamond

47Below Average
Diamond

Nutragold

Kibble

Why this score

Base score+60
powdered cellulose (mild) — ingredient #6-1
High synthetic vitamin/mineral load (1 added) — over-fortified formula-2
Unidentified generic meal (1) — sourcing unknown-7
Est. ~27% carbohydrate — multiple carb sources-6
🔴 Poor omega ratio (est. ~12:1 — typical for kibble)-10
Whole food fruits & vegetables (6)+10
Anti-inflammatory ingredients (1) — turmeric, fish oil, kelp, etc.+3

Ingredients to watch (2)

powdered cellulose mild

Powdered cellulose is wood pulp used as a cheap bulking fibre, and the comparative research is unflattering. In Beagle feeding trials (Journal of Animal Science), apparent total tract digestibility was 11% for cellulose against 29% for beet pulp — less than half. Cellulose is insoluble and poorly fermentable, so it passes through largely untouched: it reduces overall dry matter and organic matter digestibility, increases stool volume, and produces lower concentrations of beneficial short-chain fatty acids with a less acidic fecal pH than fermentable fibres. It adds bulk and satiety without feeding the gut. Fermentable fibres — beet pulp, pumpkin, chicory — do the job better.

DL-methionine mild

⚪ Synthetic form, generally safe: DL-methionine is a synthetic amino acid added to meet methionine requirements and, in some foods, to acidify urine. It's a legitimate and widely used feed additive with no evidence of harm at label levels. The 'DL-' indicates a racemic mixture — dogs use the L-form directly and convert the D-form, which they do adequately. Flagged as a formulation signal rather than a hazard: its presence usually indicates plant-heavy protein that needed topping up, since meat-based diets generally supply enough methionine on their own.

What it does well

🥦 carrots (0.1%)🥦 apples (0.1%)🥦 blueberries🥦 spinach🥦 cranberry powder🥦 parsley flake

Full ingredient list

1. chicken2. chicken meal3. barley4. egg derivatives5. ground rice6. powdered cellulose7. chicken fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols)8. salmon9. potatoes (2%)10. millet11. natural chicken flavor12. linseed13. sodium bisulphate14. ocean fish meal15. potassium chloride16. DL-methionine17. choline chloride18. dried chicory root19. taurine20. shell fish flour (a source of glucosamine)21. cartilage of poultry (a source of chondroitin sulphate)22. kelp23. carrots (0.1%)24. peas (0.1%)25. apples (0.1%)26. tomatoes27. blueberries28. spinach29. cranberry powder30. rosmary extract31. parsley flake32. yucca schidigera extract33. vitamins and minerals.

For informational and educational purposes only. This score reflects general and holistic pet-nutrition research applied to the published ingredient list. It does not diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease or condition, is not veterinary advice, and creates no veterinarian-client-patient relationship. Ingredient lists change without notice — always check the bag. Always consult a licensed veterinarian before changing your dog's diet.